Balancing Impact and Intent: Managing Workplace Behaviour During the Festive Season

Impact and Intent in the Workplace

Communication is at the core of our daily interactions. However, in the workplace, there should be a critical distinction between the impact of our actions and the intent behind them. While intent refers to the motivation or reasoning behind an individual’s behaviour, impact is the actual effect it has on others. Regardless of the intention, the impact can sometimes be far-reaching and unforeseen. As organisations navigate this dynamic, particularly with the festive season approaching, it is important to understand and manage both aspects carefully.

The Importance of Recognising Impact

It’s a common occurrence where a well-intended comment or joke lands badly, which could leave colleagues uncomfortable or upset. Despite the positive intention behind an action, if the impact is harmful or distressing, it is the impact that will determine how individuals feel and respond. This is especially true in diverse workplaces, where individual sensitivities, cultural backgrounds, and personal experiences vary significantly.

People management stated that a third (32 per cent) of UK workers have experienced bullying masked as “banter". While the intent behind these actions may have been innocent, the research highlights how even unintentional microaggressions can create lasting damage to work relationships and morale.

Similarly, someone may offer feedback in what they believe is a constructive manner, only for the recipient to perceive it as overly critical or even personal. A casual remark that one person finds humorous might come across as inappropriate or offensive to others. When these scenarios arise, it is vital for organisations to address them by focusing on the impact, not solely the intention.

Navigating Difficult Conversations

When impact and intent do not align, it is essential to tackle the issue promptly. Organisations should cultivate an environment where team members feel comfortable addressing these discrepancies. If someone has been hurt or offended, even unintentionally, the conversation should focus on the impact of the action, offering the opportunity to acknowledge, apologise, and correct the behaviour moving forward.

A 2020 report by the CIPD highlights that effective management of workplace conflict is essential for maintaining healthy employee relations. Organisations that prioritise open communication and empathy tend to foster an environment where employees feel safe to address issues before they escalate. The report suggests that nearly 50% of employees believe workplace conflict can be resolved if issues are addressed early, emphasising the importance of proactive conflict resolution strategies. Accountability plays a key role here. Rather than brushing off negative impacts because "no harm was meant," companies should encourage reflection on how to improve and prevent recurrence.

Open communication, empathy, and understanding are crucial elements to bridging the gap between impact and intent, fostering a healthier workplace culture.

The Holiday Season: Why Christmas Parties Pose a Risk

With Christmas fast approaching, companies must be especially mindful of the fine line between intent and impact. Social events such as Christmas parties can present a relaxed atmosphere where formalities of the workplace are lessened, and colleagues may act more freely. While the intent is to celebrate and enjoy time with coworkers, the potential for inappropriate or misunderstood behaviour increases.

CIPD advise when planning festive celebrations, organisations should keep in mind that workplace conduct rules extend to social gatherings. Alcohol consumption and a relaxed atmosphere at Christmas parties can lead to significant issues, from aggressive behaviour to harassment claims. Organisations have a legal duty to protect their employees, which includes work-related events. Failure to take ‘reasonable steps’ to prevent poor behaviour can lead to vicarious liability, as seen in Bellman v Northampton Recruitment Limited where the Court of Appeal found the company liable for a manager's assault on an employee during an after-party gathering. The court ruled that because the company paid for the drinks and taxis and the manager was asserting his authority, the assault was sufficiently connected to his employment, making the company vicariously liable. Employers should consider parties an extension of the workplace, applying the same standards and policies to these events, and communicating them clearly to staff beforehand.

In these environments, minor, seemingly insignificant actions can have a massive impact. A well-meaning gesture of inclusivity can be interpreted as tokenism; an innocent joke might offend someone’s cultural or religious beliefs. The festive spirit should not mean a lapse in professional conduct, and companies must recognise that inappropriate behaviour at these events can lead to long-term consequences in the workplace, affecting morale, relationships, and even legal standing.

Cautionary Steps for Companies

To mitigate potential issues, businesses should take proactive steps to manage behaviour at Christmas parties and similar events. Here are some practical recommendations:

• Set clear expectations

Companies should clearly communicate behavioural guidelines ahead of time, emphasising that parties are an extension of the workplace, and the same standards apply.

• Promote inclusivity

Ensure that all employees, regardless of background or belief, feel comfortable and included. This might mean offering non-alcoholic options or ensuring celebrations reflect diverse traditions.

• Monitor alcohol consumption

If alcohol is served, businesses should consider setting limits (such as supplying 2-3 drink “tokens” or offering alternatives to prevent overindulgence, which often leads to regrettable behaviour.

• Provide support channels

If an issue arises, it’s essential for employees to know how to report concerns confidentially and supportively. Highlighting the grievance procedure beforehand can reinforce the organisation’s stance on poor behaviour and help limit the risk of incidents.

The balance between impact and intent is crucial for maintaining a positive workplace culture. Companies need to ensure they are not just focusing on employees' intentions but also considering how those intentions are received and experienced by others. As Christmas approaches, with its potential for blurred lines, businesses must be cautious, prepared, and committed to fostering an inclusive and respectful environment. Proactiveness is key when minimising any risks within the organisation. Ultimately, creating a workplace where impact is considered as much as intent will lead to healthier, happier, and more productive teams.

Legal Island Training Resources for Your Staff

Employee Wellbeing Toolkit | eLearning Course

Are you responsible for overseeing and managing the wellbeing of all employees in your organisation?

Good mental health and wellbeing practices in the workplace are essential for us all. With an estimated 70 million workdays lost each year to poor mental health, good practices can provide not only a productive but a safe workplace for everyone.

Legal Island’s Employee Wellbeing eLearning Toolkit provides comprehensive training for all staff, ensuring every employee is aware of the importance of mental health and wellbeing in the workplace. The toolkit is designed to enable all-staff training for organisations, with 8 key mental health and well-being topic areas to choose from.

Click here to view this course employee wellbeing toolkit.